• Price




  • Type
    • Residential Homes For Sale






      Residential Homes For Lease







      Land & Lots


      Income & Commercial For Sale








  • Beds








  • Baths








  • More

































Save Search
More Less
Map List Gallery

This page contains ALL homes currently listed for sale in Shelter Island as of 10/14/2019.  You can change the search criteria at any time by utilizing the search bar above.

If you have any questions or you would like more information about any Shelter Island homes for sale or other Shelter Island Real Estate, please contact us and one of our knowledgeable REALTORS® will be pleased to assist you.

$375,000
1 BEDS  1 BATHS   625 SQFT
On Site 212 Days
$685,000
4 BEDS  2 BATHS   1,732 SQFT
On Site 66 Days
$699,000
3 BEDS  2 BATHS   1,161 SQFT
On Site 351 Days
$725,000
2 BEDS  1 BATHS  
New Listing
$759,999
5 BEDS  2 BATHS   1,850 SQFT
Price Change
$???,???
Thinking about selling?
Find your Home Value
$799,000
3 BEDS  2 BATHS   2,115 SQFT
On Site 48 Days
$799,000
3 BEDS  2 BATHS   1,456 SQFT
On Site 10 Days
$819,000
4 BEDS  3 BATHS   1,985 SQFT
On Site 118 Days
$849,000
3 BEDS  3 BATHS   2,706 SQFT
On Site 149 Days
$875,000
3 BEDS  2 BATHS   1,454 SQFT
On Site 377 Days
$885,000
3 BEDS  3 BATHS   2,150 SQFT
On Site 66 Days
$995,000
4 BEDS  4 BATHS   2,933 SQFT
On Site 187 Days
$1,150,000
4 BEDS  4 BATHS   2,436 SQFT
On Site 109 Days
$1,299,000
3 BEDS  4 BATHS   3,300 SQFT
On Site 182 Days
$1,475,000
5 BEDS  4 BATHS  
Price Change
$1,599,000
8 BEDS  4 BATHS   2,812 SQFT
On Site 44 Days
$1,725,000
3 BEDS  3 BATHS   2,972 SQFT
Price Change
$1,795,000
3 BEDS  2 BATHS   1,425 SQFT
New Listing
$3,795,000
5 BEDS  4 BATHS   3,325 SQFT
On Site 21 Days
$3,992,000
4 BEDS  4 BATHS   2,800 SQFT
On Site 110 Days
$8,995,000
22 BEDS  18 BATHS   11,465 SQFT
On Site 45 Days
The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of the Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc. Real Estate listings held by brokerage firms other than First Flag Realty Inc are marked with the Broker Reciprocity logo and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers.

Information Copyright 2019, Multiple Listing Service of Long Island, Inc.
Property Saved
Property Removed



One Moment Please..

Sign Up For A Free Account
We'll email you when we find properties that match your needs!
Receive notifications of New Listings & Price Changes.




Example: 801-111-2222

Search Smarter
  • New Listing Email Alerts
  • Price Change Alerts
  • All Detailed MLS Info
  • Photos, Tours & Videos
  • Save your Favorite Homes
  • Save Searches
  • Find Your Home Value
  • Agents Online to Answer Questions
  • Maps & Property Street View

Already Registered? Sign In.
By registering on our site you agree to our terms & privacy policy.